“A Celebration of Difference”
Review of Stargirl and Love, Stargirl, Jerry Spinelli,
Kara Martin
Jerry Spinelli is an award-winning author for teenagers, known for his witty dialogue, his mix of fantasy and realism, and his unforgettable characters. Stargirl is one of those characters. Stargirl chose her own name and changed it by deed poll. As the cover says she is: “as magical as the desert sky. As strange as her pet rat. As mysterious as her own name.”
Stargirl has been homeschooled, but decides she should give high school a go. She goes in true to herself: a dancing, ukulele-playing, rat-loving, colourful-dressing enigma. At first the other kids see her as a freak, but she wears them down with her cheerfulness and kindness and intelligence. She then becomes popular, although she wasn’t looking for that.
However the other students turn on her after she, as a cheerleader, congratulates the opposition basketball team on good play when they win. The narrator of the book, Leo, has fallen in love with her, but finds he has to make a choice, between Stargirl, and the rest of the school. He ends up trying to get both by telling her she must change, conform, fit in.
That is the crisis moment for the first book, and also sets the scene for the sequel. At first Stargirl tries to follow what Leo wants, but not being true to herself has terrible consequences for her identity and self-esteem, and for Leo. In the end, in a glorious moment, she chooses to be true, even if it means being unpopular, and losing the love of her life. In the second book, she examines her feelings for Leo, and the choices she made, as well as continuing to live her colourful life bring grace and joy into the lives of others.
I think the Stargirl books should be mandatory for teenagers! It is about identity and self-esteem being rooted in something other than consumerism and popularity. It exposes the whole cult of celebrity that is around us. It is a coming of age novel, about first love, and life choices. It speaks to that critical issue of “who am I apart from my parents and my peers” that confronts all teenagers. Both books are about bringing joy to others, and building community, and finding connections that are meaningful.
But do they communicate to teenagers? My teenage daughter said: “I really love these books because they aren’t like any other books. In all other books, the characters are normal people just like us, but Stargirl is different. She has a different opinion to everyone else on every single subject. She likes to make herself heard, whereas others would prefer just to stay in the corner. She gets out her ukulele at lunchtime in the Cafeteria and sings ‘Happy Birthday’ to whoever’s birthday it is.
“I also really enjoyed these books because the love is subtle and not ‘out there’ like other books, and is perfect in the amount of lovey-dovey stuff provided for the age group it’s written for. I was challenged by these two books to be creative in my opinion of life, and in the way I look after and care for others. I would definitely recommend these books to anyone, boy or girl, who loves a quirky read and enjoys reading about someone’s opinion on when they first fall in love.”
These are terrific books, creative, part real and part legend, wonderful values. They are an antidote to the apparent celebrity-obsessed, self-focused images of modern youth. I think reading these books would make us all think about the compromises we make to our true selves, to fit in or conform.
Open House book reviewer KARA MARTIN is a lecturer with Macquarie Christian Studies Institute (www.mcsi.edu.au), and is an avid reader and book group attendee.