Last week Andrew Bolt, a journalist with the Sun Herald newspaper, made some comments that I must share with you. Rarely has a self-described agnostic described my feelings and frustrations—and those of many I know—so well.
In his article entitled ‘My Easter Message’, Bolt highlighted the double-standard that exists in ridiculing holy things, especially Jesus Christ.
Bolt says, ‘While the ABC refused to show the Danish cartoons of Mohammed, for fear of God knows what mayhem, it had no such fear this week of mocking Jesus… Its Triple J station held "Jesus, you've got talent!" – a talent quest for singing toga wearers and the like.
‘Chicago's School of Art Institute, meanwhile, displayed an art work showing Christ resurrected as Democrat presidential candidate Barack Obama, son of a Muslim-born Kenyan. And New York's Lab Gallery unveiled a life-sized [nude] Jesus made of chocolate...’
‘[It's] tame stuff given what we've seen before,’ Bolt adds.
‘Who can forget Piss Christ, the crucifix plopped in a jar of urine at the National Gallery of Victoria? Or the Chris Ofili picture of the Virgin Mary, decorated with cow dung, which the National Gallery of Australia tried to bring in? Or the ABC's Christmas special of 1999 – a comparison of the Sistine Chapel's religious frescoes with the paintings made by hip British artists Gilbert and George of their semen, faeces, spit and blood?’
Bolt continues: ‘I wouldn't be alone in thinking each time an artist or commentator insults Christians: friend, if you're so brave, say that about Islam. Show us your chocolate Mohammeds. Show us your Korans dipped in urine.’
‘It's not as if Islam doesn't threaten our artists more than does Christianity. See only the murder of film director Theo van Gogh or the fatwa on writer Salman Rushdie or the stabbing of Rushdie's translator. Or see those deadly riots against the Mohammed cartoons.
‘So when I see a Western artist mock Christ,’ Bolt says, ‘I see an artist advertising not his courage but his cowardice – by not daring to mock what would threaten him more.
‘I am most certainly not saying that moderate Islam should now be treated with the childish disrespect so often shown to Christianity,’ Bolt adds. ‘But I am saying that more people now know there is a double standard here, illustrated perfectly by the Melbourne International Comedy Festival, which banned acts that told jokes against Muslims but promoted ones that lampooned Christians.
‘It's no accident that we feel safer insulting Christians than trashing almost anyone else,’ Bolt says. ‘This is a religion that's always preached tolerance, reason and non-violence, even if too many of its followers have seemed deaf.
‘It's also urged us to leave the judgment of others to God… We are the beneficiaries of that preaching, even those of us who aren't Christians. We live in a society, founded on Christian principles, that guards our right to speak, and even to abuse things we should praise.
‘We can now vilify Jesus and damn priests… We dare all that because we do not actually fear what we condemn. We know Christians are taught not to punch our smarmy face, and we even count on it. Indeed, it is the very faith we mock that has made us so safe.’
Andrew Bolt’s words there in last week’s Sun Herald. All I can say is, thank you Andrew. You’ve highlighted the double standard so many of us have felt: as far as popular opinion goes, it seems wrong to ridicule religion – unless it’s Jesus.